By US President Rejects Dr. Aafia Siddiqui’s Clemency Request: Islamabad High Court Hearing Update
In a significant development, the Islamabad High Court (IHC) was informed on Friday. That Dr. Aafia Siddiqui’s clemency petition had been denied by the President of the United States. This information was presented to a single bench of the IHC, headed by Justice Sardar Ejaz Ishaq Khan, during the ongoing hearing of a constitutional petition filed by Dr. Aafia sister, Dr. Fowzia Siddiqui. The petition seeks the release of Dr. Aafia Siddiqui, who is currently serving a sentence in a US prison.
Details of the Clemency Petition Rejection
During the court hearing, Dr. Aafia Siddiqui’s lawyer, Imran Shafi. Revealed that former US President Joe Biden had rejected the clemency request for Dr. Aafia. Additionally, the United States had declined any prisoner exchange arrangement with Pakistan. Dr. Fowzia Siddiqui and her US attorney, Clive Smith, participated in the proceedings via video link. While the additional attorney general (AAG) of Pakistan also appeared in court.
US-Pakistan Diplomatic Efforts and Concerns Raised
The court was informed that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MoFA) had submitted a report in response to the court’s inquiries. The report included details of foreign visits by Pakistan’s Prime Minister and Foreign Minister. But revealed that Pakistan’s ambassador to the US had not been involved in key meetings regarding Dr. Aafia’s case. Justice Ishaq expressed disappointment over the lack of tangible progress. And remarked that the United States was not valuing Pakistan’s efforts.
Criticism of US Administration and Diplomatic Oversight
Justice Ishaq criticized the US administration, highlighting the contrast in the treatment of US citizens compared to Pakistani nationals. He pointed out that while former President Biden had pardoned his own son, no similar clemency had been granted to Dr. Aafia Siddiqui, despite her longstanding imprisonment.
Court’s Decision to Defer Hearing
Due to the ongoing diplomatic challenges, the IHC bench deferred further proceedings for two weeks, allowing time for additional updates and actions to be taken. During the previous hearing, the MoFA had stated that no response had been received to Prime Minister’s letter. Sent to President Joe Biden on October 13, 2024, requesting clemency for Dr. Aafia.
Diplomatic Lapses and Expectations for Pakistan’s Representation
Justice Ishaq, in his written order, expressed concern over the absence of Pakistan’s ambassador at key meetings from December 3rd to 11th, when crucial discussions on Dr. Aafia’s case were taking place. He emphasized the need for the ambassador to be more proactive in supporting Pakistan’s position. And taking action in line with the government’s written support for Dr. Aafia’s clemency request. You can also visit.
The IHC bench directed the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to obtain feedback from the Pakistani Embassy. And submit a concise report on this matter during the next hearing. Additionally, MoFA was instructed to provide a detailed list of the Prime Minister’s and Foreign Minister’s foreign visits, including destinations and durations, since the clemency petition was filed with the US Department of Justice.
Conclusion: Continuing Legal and Diplomatic Efforts
As the IHC continues its proceedings, the future of Dr. Aafia Siddiqui’s case remains uncertain. The rejection of her clemency plea by the US President marks a challenging moment for her supporters and legal advocates. The Pakistani government is expected to intensify its diplomatic efforts to secure Dr. Aafia’s release, with a continued focus on addressing concerns raised by the court and strengthening diplomatic ties with the United States.
